Colin Bayley is the common bond between four complete strangers. For Natalie, he was a breath of fresh air that brought her back to life. For Tenille, he was the co-star in her personal "Meg Ryan" movie. For Gavin, he was an unexpected surprise. For Raya, he was everything. 

As the four strangers meet to share their personal histories with the same man, it is clear that their memories are not all pleasant ones. In recounting their experiences with him, they hint that there was more to the charming Mr. Bayley than they want to admit. There was something dark.

In trying to discern just exactly who their common friend is and why they were so drawn to him, they can truly agree on only one thing. Colin Bayley was the perfect man... until he wasn't.